I was initially going to sit the World of Warcraft book release for D&D 5.5 out, figuring that A: I had stopped playing World of Warcraft the MMORPG a long time ago, and B: I never ran any tabeltop games with the prior editions of D20 3.5 compatible World of Warcraft back in the day, so would it really make sense to expect I would do so now, so many years after burning out on the game it is based on?
When I took a look at the games in the FLGS however, I was drawn to something about the books, their presentation, art and design: they were interesting, and despite it feeling like it doesn't contain nearly enough information to capture the full scope of World of Warcraft at the game table, it nonetheless did a fantastic job of capturing "just enough of it." But there was something more, too....something I couldn't quite put my finger on until I started reading the book in more depth and got the itch to actually use it for a campaign. Which, by the way, kudos to the designers of D&D WoW for making me actively consider de-mothballing my 5.5 books just to run this!
That "thing" that the D&D WoW books have, I finally realized, is a consistent, unwavering and long-running vision for what the World of Warcraft is. As I pulled out the 5.5 PHB, DMG and MM and contrasted those with the WoW book I realized that Warcraft as its own MMO genre and universe looks fully recognizable and consistent to me, and it evokes a sense of adventure, conflict, mystery, comedy at times and horror at other time. It's branding, for lack of a better word, is on target and comfortably familiar in a way that I both recognize and appreciate. The 5.5 edition of D&D, by contrast, looks like an entirely different game from prior editions of D&D, one in which there's a lot more gaiety, whimsy, lack of danger, and a need to show chill and cozy fun more often then adventure. The art direction of D&D 5.5 is distinctly different from how it has been portrayed in prior editions, and focused heavily on what in the video game world has been labeled Cozy Gaming.* Wow - not so much, it's "cozy" only in the sense that if you are a veteran player of the MMO this game will have a comfortable sense of familiarity to you, but that familiarity is immediately reminding me of exciting adventures, harrowing events, unique emergent play from the game, and a general sense of a deep world that earns the war part of its name. And it's orcs, even after decades, still look and act like orcs, as do all of the other many species in Warcraft. It's consistent, and it did not make changes for change's sake, respecting its own lore**
I don't know if the new WoW book for D&D will get me to play 5.5 again; I may see how easy it is to retrofit it into the older D&D 5.0 books, which I have grown increasingly to respect more and more (even for their design flaws), if only because those still look and feel (and read) like D&D as it has always previously existed. But this has made me actually consider checking out WoW Forever, the new evergreen edition of the game. So....kudos to Blizzard and the design team for this book! Maybe, with any luck, WotC will learn something here about why branding and legacy matters in an IP. I can only hope.
Also, its really nice to see what look like Real Orcs (or as close to it as you can get) in the new book!
*This cozy gaming style is especially prevalent in the art of the Arcana Unleashed book from earlier in the year. It's whimsical take on magicians getting up to amusing antics in the art may be lost on me due to the fact that I was already an adult when Harry Potter hit the scene, so I am missing a generational connection to this kind of chill and cozy fantasy style.
**We will ignore deep dive WoWhead lore masters arguing over the time traveling conundrums presented by various new expansions in the MMORPG.
No comments:
Post a Comment