Tuesday, June 25, 2019

Film Review: X-Men: Dark Phoenix

Dark Phoenix suffers for several reasons. The key problems this film faces include the following:

1. It's a sequel to X-Men Apocalypse, which was the weakest of the rebooted series so far, and as a result it continues with a bunch of characters that didn't get the best setup in the prior film to begin with.

2. It's a franchise that Marvel fans are convinced is imminently going to be rebooted into the Marvel Cinematic Universe by Disney. This probably will happen, but I will predict we won't see it for at least 5 or more years.

3. It's taking on the most infamous and well-remembers storyline from the old Byrne/Claremont days of the X-Men during it's heyday, a hard story to adapt to film without making serious concessions.

4. No Hugh Jackman, which means we could not have a squicky Wolverine/Jean Grey/Cyclops love triangle.

5. According to some sources, it was slated for a February release but as booted up due to a conflict with Battle Angel Alita. This shows; the film is a darker, broodier story that would suit a winter audience's sensibilities better....it was clearly not meant to be summer popcorn wahoo fare.

All of that aside, I actually really enjoyed Dark Phoenix and felt like, taken in itself, the film was a better follow-up to X-Men First Class and Days of Future Past (two films I greatly enjoyed), and that if it were possible to simply forget about the existence of Apocalypse then Dark Phoenix might have been even better.

Now, taken in and of itself, Dark Phoenix did a lot right. Chief among these were that it kept the run time to two hours, and as a result had a rather tight and a clean storyline. This despite what I understand were a lot of reshoots and edits, which apparently were meant to fix some glaring issues from test audiences and also maybe to tighten it up as an end to the four part X-Men run.

The actual story made me more empathetic to the Jean Grey character; the actress always struck me as more of a "Jean Grey cosplayer" but I am told she's actually well known from Game of Thrones (something I have never watched, ain't got that sort of time!) so whadda I know. Still, she managed to do a much better performance here than in Apocalypse.

The story also tried....as best it could....to incorporate some elements of the original Dark Phoenix saga in to it. There's the threat of the Phoenix Force as a world-eating malevolence. There's an alien race (not the Shi'ar, alas) who seek to bring it to justice or harness it, or something. Jean Grey's transformation from confused mutant to omnipotent power is underplayed but works well for me, and it probably helps that they establish early on that she was never really that ethical to begin with (the story delves into some early childhood trauma, mutant style).

Overall....I felt this was worth my time to see, and appreciated what they tried to do here with the final non-MCU version of the X-Men before some future reboot happens. The movie remains a victim of this Summer's film apocalypse, and perhaps rightly so, but I definitely had more fun with this than Godzilla KOTM or Hellboy. Solid B+


  1. Good to see you back. I heard Phoenix's ending got reshot because the original more cosmic ending might have conflicted with Endgame. That X-Men cameo in Deadpool 2 was shot during the filming of this film.

    The Phoenix Saga is tailor-made for Marvel cinematic treatment. They could probably even expand on it to include the Avengers. However, for this to work, they've got to focus on the characters, not the social commentary, not beyond the first Marvel X-Men film at most.

    1. I'll have to rewatch that scene from Deapdpool 2, I really thought those were all stand-in actors! On the social commentary...both Dark Phoenix and Apocalypse are pretty anemic on this, beyond "we should be afraid of mutants who can kill us with great ease," which might be a hard fit for the MCU, where things seem generally friendlier.

  2. http://jdh417.blogspot.com/2017/12/how-x-men-will-enter-marvel-cinematic.html

    I wrote something about this a while back. It's a bit out-of-date, but does question how Marvel will handle mutants.

    1. That was a great review of the MCU/X-Men situation, well thought out. You're completely right, the X-Men are a bit convoluted and difficult to adapt to the MCU and also a bit too edgy for Disney. One thought I had...probably to be clarified a bit when Spider-Man: Far From Home comes out next week, is if this new idea of alternate universes is intended to introduce concepts like the X-Men in their own universe, without directly impacting the MCU. That, to me, would still make the most sense for the cinematic universe, even if it doesn't necessarily accomplish what I would most like to see (which is a Magneto/Captain America/Wolverine meet up). Also, you are 100% right about the Inhumans issue, and I still wonder how it is that no one at Marvel/Disney did not see this, beyond the idea that maybe they were hoping the Inhumans really could serve as direct cyphers for the X-Men somehow.